25%, Individual. Launches Week 3. Due Week 7.

Ethics Case Analysis

Pick one deployed technology where something went wrong or something went right, name the human decision that produced the outcome, and propose fixes. The Week 3 lab on Allegheny and LA County was practice for this.

Assignment

Submit two things on Canvas by the start of class in Week 7 (October 21):

  1. A document of at most 3 pages (about 2 pages for written testimony).
  2. A 5-minute audio walkthrough, a voice memo in which you explain your case in your own words. A phone recording is fine.

The case and research plan was due in Week 5. Download the analysis template for the default mode.

Case selection

Pick a harm case or a success case from the case bank, or a case outside the bank that you named in your Week 5 plan. For a success case, also say what made it work and whether it would continue without the people who championed it.

Analysis modes

  • Analysis (default): five sections for readers inside the class.
  • Consultation note: a note to one colleague who is deciding about a technology, at most 3 pages.
  • Written testimony: testimony to a board or council, about 2 pages, recorded as audio. The recording counts as the walkthrough.

The five sections of the default analysis, as in the template:

  1. System description. What it is, who it acts on, and what its output triggers in a person’s life.
  2. Sociotechnical protocol. Your answers to the sociotechnical protocol.
  3. Decisive decision. The decision that determined the outcome, with evidence.
  4. Values analysis. Values from your ethics code applied to specific parts of the system.
  5. Mitigation. Two or three changes, each with someone who could make it.

Ethics code and sources

Use the NASW Code of Ethics with the NASW Technology Standards, or the code of your own field, or an AI governance framework such as the NIST AI Risk Management Framework or the OECD AI Principles.

Base your evidence on primary sources such as court rulings, audits, agency documents, and original reporting. If you used AI, add a short disclosure line: which tool, what for, and the prompts.

Rubric (100 points, scaled to 25%)

Case and research plan (due Week 5, 15 points)

Points for the case and research plan, by criterion
CriterionPoints
Case and mode5
Primary sources5
AI research plan5

Analysis (due Week 7, 85 points)

Points for the finished analysis, by criterion
CriterionPoints
Sociotechnical analysis: the protocol applied, and the outcome tied to a specific decision25
Professional ethics: values from your code applied to parts of the system20
Mitigation: changes, each with someone who could make them20
Audio walkthrough10
Format and sources: the mode’s structure and length, and claims checked against sources10